
- Cara Eastwood Baldwin
Former Republican U.S. Senator Alan Simpson and President Clinton’s former White House Chief of Staff Erskine Bowles have laid out a bold plan for reducing the national debt.
I just had to give them an earful about reducing or eliminating my mortgage deduction. This would represent a huge tax increase on me – not to mention my fellow members of the middle class.
Simpson and Bowles just laughed me off, as you can see from this photo.
Bottom line: Nobody is going to like everything about this plan, but without it, America is surely going to be belly-up broke. Simpson and Bowles hope that as they eliminate cherished deductions they can also lower tax rates and broaden the tax base.
There’s a lot of harsh but needed medicine in their plan. I don’t like it. But I am afraid we need it.
And I laud Simpson and Bowles for keeping their solution to 57, very readable pages when many commissions can’t even stop at 1,000. Click here to read their report.
And Click here to read my column on the Simpson and Bowles.

December 11, 2010
Doing away with the home mortgage interest deduction would be disastrous for the middle class. In essence, we’d be making the middle class homeowners pay the lion’s share of the deficit while relieving the wealthy (who own unencumbered homes) of paying for part of it. It would shift the burden to the middle class. It would also further drop the home-builder and other related industries into the hole–who would buy a home, even when they put 20% down, when they get no deduction? Also, people like me in the middle class bought a home in reliance of that deduction–should the government be permitted to change the rules of the 30-year game in the middle of it?! This is serious. I hang around Republicans, and I’m dismayed that a lot of people actually think it should be seriously considered, saying things like “Europe doesn’t have it”, and “People need to be more responsible about what they spend for a home.” Either of those, as I’m sure you know, are easily refuted. We really need to ween ourselves off the China crap and get more jobs here, NOT hurt the middle class and deepen this recession.