So much dirty laundry has come out during the past year’s financial mayhem it’s a wonder I still have the capacity to be shocked. This piece of news shocks me: “Calpers, the nation’s largest public pension fund, is launching a ‘special review’ of fees paid by some of its money managers to an investment advisory firm run by a former Calpers board member,” the WSJ reports online. It turns out some $50 million in fees were paid over five years to Arvco Financial Ventures LLC, headed by former Calpers board member Al Villalobos. Some poor-performing investments made by Calpers were recommended by Arvco. You might wonder why I’m so stunned by this news. Since Bear Stearns and Lehman, we’ve had all manner of appalling revelations thrown in our faces, underscoring that our national well-being was in the clutches of the unfit or immoral. It still amazes me that establishment pillars such as Calpers, which manages the wealth of thousands (maybe millions) of California public employees, would be run by a coterie of mutual back-scratchers. Of course, we recently learned that New York’s state fund exhibited similar traits; but California, too? Say it isn’t so! The other day some colleagues were teasing me – saying my criticism of so many titans of finance suggests I’m turning into a “socialist.” Nah, I’m fairly sure people behave badly in just about any economic or political system. In fact, it’s a sign of my visceral faith in free markets’ logic and inherent parameters that I’m still capable of being surprised and dismayed when they go awry. All that’s happening to me – and, I believe, many of you – is that we’re yet again being reminded of the frailty of human nature and the importance of defending oneself, one’s loved ones, and one’s nest eggs against the likelihood that the guardians of wealth are out to increase their own wealth, not ours. Consider this story by the NYT’s Julie Cresswell, which appeared last week. Despite a few thinly reported passages, it’s very well done – and, yes, it reminds one that private equity titans will first and foremost extract massive dividends from acquired companies – and secondarily worry about the health and well-being of the enterprise and its employees. Have a look: human frailty is on full display.
2 Comments to Calpers And ‘Pay To Play’
October 15, 2009
How does someone not go to jail here? Doesn’t CALPERS have a higher responsibility ie public trust. See the article yesterday on the $500 million they stand to lose as their equity investment in a New York City Real Estate project. What are they doing making direct investments anyway.

October 14, 2009
I think the reason we like democracy is that we don’t want the folks who run private companies to be running the government as well. Or vice versa. In a socialist country you wouldn’t be allowed to criticize them – this may or may not be an accurate version of your colleagues tease
In a free market there is some limit to the amount of damage the crooks can do. Not a small limit, but still better than no limit……